The First Descendant is characterized by stunning graphics and a diverse array of character options, appealing to fans of looter shooters and offering significant free-to-play content. However, criticism arises from the grind-centric progression, a strong reliance on microtransactions, and inconsistent updates that focus heavily on sexualized cosmetics. While the gameplay provides enough to keep players entertained with regular updates, the performance and connection issues detract from its potential, leaving a mixed yet somewhat promising impression for those seeking a casual shooting experience.

The general sentiment towards the game is positive, with many players enjoying the fluid movement mechanics and distinctive atmosphere. The game's narrative and environmental storytelling receive mixed responses, with some players appreciating the minimalism, while others desire a more cohesive plot. Despite technical issues faced by a minority and level design challenges in particular levels, the overall experience and the depth provided by features like multiplayer and secrets are highly praised.

The immersive world, engaging story, and historical accuracy are celebrated aspects of the game, creating a rich RPG experience. However, players find the combat system to be clunky and the save system frustrating. The balance between realism and gameplay enjoyment is debated, with some appreciating it and others finding it tedious. Overall, the game is viewed as a masterpiece with caveats.

The story and character development are the main attractions of Persona 5 Royal, with many reviewers expressing that the game has become a personal and impactful experience. The soundtrack and art style further enhance the overall aesthetic appeal, making it a visually and audibly memorable game. However, there is some criticism about the game's length and lengthy cutscenes that some feel could make the experience tedious. Technical issues and a perceived lack of challenge without DLC Personas also present minor problems for some players, but the game's engaging gameplay and deep character interactions continue to make it a commendable JRPG experience for newcomers and veterans alike.