Overall, reviews highlight the fun and humor of the game, spotlighting its appeal in multiplayer settings as players appreciate the unique blend of fishing and shooting mechanics. However, there are challenges noted with technical issues and bugs, impacting the smoothness of gameplay. While many enjoy its value for money, others find the game's short length and limited content disappointing. Players are split on the mixed nature of the combination of fishing, shooting, and gambling mechanics, with some seeing it as a highlight and others feeling it's a weak implementation.

The general sentiment among players is that this game is a solid-enough entry into the Souls-like genre, offering unique customization options and a visually appealing world. However, issues with checkpoint placement and enemy balancing are considerable obstacles to enjoyment and progression. Some players find the shell system intriguing yet restricting, as it can limit their desired gameplay style. While the game is well-received for its approach to combat and performance, frequent technical issues and frustrations with progression mechanics temper some of the enthusiasm.

The immersive world, engaging story, and historical accuracy are celebrated aspects of the game, creating a rich RPG experience. However, players find the combat system to be clunky and the save system frustrating. The balance between realism and gameplay enjoyment is debated, with some appreciating it and others finding it tedious. Overall, the game is viewed as a masterpiece with caveats.

The general sentiment of the reviews is highly positive, with players appreciating the game's smooth movement, stunning brutalist aesthetic, and engaging atmosphere. The community features like workshop support are also applauded. However, there are some critiques regarding the lack of narrative depth and occasional technical issues, which some players experience. Overall, the unique mix of easy-to-learn mechanics with a high skill ceiling, and the freedom to explore creatively, grants the game high praise in the indie movement genre community.