Overall, players are divided but many enjoy the game as a stylish, challenging modern metroidvania, praising whip-based movement and varied combat, striking environments and secrets, and the return of a new 2D Castlevania. The biggest practical concern is black-screen launch failures, stuttering, and input bugs, while opinions remain split over its departure from classic Castlevania, its controls, and its soundtrack.

The general sentiment is overwhelmingly positive, with players lauding the game as a highly replayable and engaging roguelike experience. The game is often highlighted for its soundtrack, character variety, and multiplayer enjoyment. However, concerns about DLC pricing and multiplayer connectivity serve as common criticisms. Overall, players appreciate the intricate gameplay loop and the unique thrill of each run, though some struggle with the learning curve brought on by a lack of navigational tools.

Overall sentiment is polarized: fans still value tactical gunplay and tense, rewarding matches, particularly with friends, while many others are frustrated by cheaters and weak anti-cheat enforcement, crashes, lag, and connection problems, and punishing matchmaking for newcomers. The slow, demanding pace and bot-filled or inconsistent lobbies can either suit players seeking a strategic battle royale or make matches feel drawn-out and unfair.

Overall sentiment is strongly favorable: players frequently praise fast, satisfying combat, improved level design, and the added Sister of Battle, and many consider it a worthy step up from the original. The main caveats are severe performance drops in some Nurgle levels and occasional progression bugs, alongside disagreement over how much the sequel improves on the first and whether its price is justified.