The game features a strong balance between survival horror and action elements, drawing praise for its engaging gameplay and nostalgic callbacks to previous Resident Evil entries. However, the dual protagonist structure with Grace and Leon led to divided opinions on pacing and gameplay style, with some players feeling occasional technical issues and narrative missteps. While the graphics and technical performance were widely appreciated, mixed views on gameplay repetitiveness and plot predictability impacted the overall reception.

Overall, the reviews reflect a revitalization of the Resident Evil franchise through a strong return to survival horror roots. Players appreciate the immersive atmosphere and engaging story, particularly praising the characterization of the Baker family. However, there are some criticisms regarding enemy variety and an underwhelming final boss. The DLCs received reviews; they add extra depth but can sometimes feel disconnected from the main game. Despite some issues, the game is considered a horror masterpiece by many.

Players generally find the remake to be a faithful adaptation of the original Gothic, capturing its unique atmosphere and challenging gameplay. However, the game is marred by significant performance issues and an overly complex lockpicking mechanic, which impacts the overall experience. While the game design faithfully brings back what fans loved about Gothic, it also comes with combat mechanics that receive mixed reviews for being both challenging and clunky.

Reviews reflect a fun multiplayer experience with effective horror elements. Players consistently note performance issues and bugs that detract from the overall enjoyment. Despite these problems, many find the game to be a valuable purchase for the amount of content and scares it provides. The game's design is seen as optimizable but enjoyable with friends.