Overall, the reviews suggest a highly engaging game for those who enjoy complex strategy and role-playing elements, though it is hindered by some technical issues and controversial DLC pricing. Players appreciate the rich storytelling potential and modding capabilities, but are critical of the game's bugs and expensive expansions. Despite its flaws, many find the game to be immersive and rewarding.

The general sentiment is cautiously optimistic, with players praising the game's tactical combat and story despite some frustrating issues with character creation and performance. There is a recognition that as an Early Access title, it has room to grow, and many players are hopeful that the final release will address these current drawbacks and deliver a refined experience.

Graphics, world design, and combat are consistently praised as strengths that uphold the Diablo series' dark, atmospheric universe. However, server stability and performance issues, particularly for solo players and those on platforms like the Steam Deck, pose significant challenges. The campaign elicits varied reactions, with its darker, gothic tone appreciated but generally lacking the depth expected by series veterans. Monetization strategies significantly taint many players' experiences, with aggressive microtransactions and pricing models heavily criticized. Despite these issues, the seasonal updates and the introduction of new classes like the Paladin bring some players back, suggesting patches may provide ongoing potential if core systemic issues are addressed.

Overall, players have expressed enthusiasm for Timberborn, noting its unique water mechanics and charming beaver theme. The game is praised for its replayability and development process, although recent changes and performance issues have been criticized. The automation update also received divided opinions. Mixed feelings about the game's difficulty and tutorial suggest room for improvement in guidance and late-game objectives.